Was ShopNBC Trying To Stick It To HSN By Selling The Exact Same Ring, Touted As ‘Rare’ By The Southern Channel, At A Cheaper Price?

HSN customers were not happy campers when they saw that ShopNBC was selling the same ring as HSN at a lower price

HSN customers are complaining that a carved coral rose ring the home shopping network offered as a Today’s Special July 15 was being sold the next day on rival network ShopNBC — at a lower price.

And to add insult to injury, the HSN ring is part of the popular “Rarities” line. How “rare” are your pieces when your competitor has them on soon after you — at a less expensive price point?

We’ve been watching electronic retailing for several decades now, and we can’t recall two home shopping channels hawking the exact same piece of jewelry.

Here’s the deal. Back on July 15 Carol Brodie, who we love, as HSN’s Today’s Special. It was a ring with peachy pink carved coral roses with white topaz accents, and its TS price was for $90.

We blogged about it.

Well, ShopNBC’s Gem Treasures line by in-house jewelry designer Chuck Clemency had what appears to be the exact same ring, with the carved coral roses.

The only difference between the two rings was that HSN’s ring used white topaz for accents, while ShopNBC’s had white zircons. Oh, and there was that price differential.

The ShopNBC ring went on sale shortly after the HSN one for just $79, compared to HSN’s TV price of $xx. Now, the coral ring is priced at $ 130 at HSN, and $xxx at ShopNBC.

HSN customers were the one’s that tipped us off to this situation. They posted complaints on HSN.com.

Here are some of them:

“Beautiful.. not sure it’s a rarity?…I was thrilled when I received this yesterday, it is truly beautiful piece of jewelry, looks very italian and feminine. Mine was very coral in color, a soft blush peachy pink. I love everything about it and will keep it, however I was a bit dissapointed to see the exact same ring on shopnbc.com (item 320614) for $78.62 (regular price $98.75). It is identical down to the carvings on the side the platinum plating, the white topaz. I thought Carol’s pieces were unique and designed by her, so this makes me doubt if what she is bringing is truly original or if hers was copied. I will keep it anyway, highly recommend!”

Blingrat (we love that name) wrote, “Too oversized to be wearable. And it is not exclusive! Saw it 2 days later on competitor’s channel at $21 less!”

Another poster said, “The ring is pretty but the color is not uniform and it is more expensive than else where. It is $ 78.96 on another network that is their regular price for this exact ring Not a Today’s special. I am thinking whether to keep it or return it.”

We asked HSN and ShopNBC on Monday what gives. That’s why we sat on the story.

ShopNBC said they were looking into it, but never got back to us. We can’t help but wonder, were the folks in Minnesota trying to stick it to HSN by putting their coral ring up for sale right after HSN has it as a TS?

HSN said that its ring had been in production for almost a year.

“Carol Brodie is constantly searching for exciting discoveries to bring to our customers and has had great success over the last year,” an HSN flak said. “Her carved coral and white topaz ring is rated as a ‘customer pick’ based upon online reviews. We look forward to introducing new additions from Carol in the coming months.”

Hmmmn, we are definately thinking that ShopNBC tried to screw HSN, by embarrassing the No. 2 home shopping channel, sticking a pin in the “Rarities” claim and showing it underprices HSN.

Tags: , , , , , , , ,

3 Responses to “Was ShopNBC Trying To Stick It To HSN By Selling The Exact Same Ring, Touted As ‘Rare’ By The Southern Channel, At A Cheaper Price?”

  1. stefF Says:

    ya know……..this is my opinion only…….but i think C. Clemency is the “knockoff king”…….personally speaking, not too fond of his cheap imitation; he constantly reinvents the line……would NEVER buy from him….i do think, however, that it was a “bound-to-happen” moment…..too bad….makes both channels look bad i think, but not surprising for C. Clemency

  2. Leslie Jackson Says:

    Had quite a laugh reading this article re Carol Brodie = Chuck Clemency hand carved pink flower sea coral ring.
    HIS zircon better than HER topaz.
    All this aside.
    Clemency ring been out there longer than Brodie’s.

    Brodie is the one who should be embarrassed.
    Her prices way over the limit of reason and pricing
    inexpensive silver settings
    NOT rare gems
    And putting Kyanite into a necklace = necklace won’t last a year
    Kyanite is the softest gemstone on the market – and cheap to buy.
    Can’t even use tweezers on it
    And does anyone believe she designs her own rings?
    I get embarrassed, for her, whenever she opens her mouth.

    And HSN should be embarrassed. Their sales pitch
    … ladies, buy it now, won’t make it to the end of the show …
    Can’t tell you how many times have seen it still for sale on the Internet,
    the day after, or the day after that. Just to name one thing.

    These companies are in SALES.
    They have no compunction lying to customers.
    And they make a killing with their shipping fees.
    So much is defective and returned and doubles cost to customer.
    And in the end, they always make a profit.


  3. Val Says:

    I seriously do not think HSN and/or Carol B are accusing Chuck C of copying the design, although I am curious to see if Carol will address the question when she is on HSN tomorrow. The thing is, either he did, or she is not being truthful when she markets her jewelry. She sold that ring with the representation that she designed it with the inspiration coming from a bouquet of flowers given to her by her children and husband. So it’s rather too coincidental that Chuck could come out with a ring that is virtually identical. With all due respect, Ms. Homeshoppingista, it’s a strange spin you are putting on it to suggest that ShopNBC sold this ring to embarrass HSN. Even if they did, I think in this case, HSN and Carol B have every real reason to be embarrassed.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: